Recently on HackADay.com there was an article called “FT8: SAVING HAM RADIO OR KILLING IT?” which drew fire from some and praise from others. The article title itself was a little click-bait-y but justifiable. According to the source article over at flexradio.com FT8 lovers and haters are split almost 50/50. Some say its awful because FT8 doesn’t permit “real” contacts, and others love it because of its obvious benefits. I highly recommend reading the article- it’s quite good and has some excellent insights. But be sure you come back here when you’re done. This article is as much a response to the HaD article as it is to the flexradio.com article.
FT8 Is great, but…
Is FT8 ruining ham radio? Is it saving it? It is neither. It is a fantastic mode with a lot of potential out it certainly has made amateur radio interesting even during a solar minimum.
But I think that there is something that is saving ham radio. At a time when the solar cycle is at an all-time low, it is surprising that there is a resurgence a type of radio that generally relies on excellent propagation to make contacts: QRP. QRP typically means less than 10w output on SSB (voice) signals and less than 5w on CW (Morse Code) or digital modes, depending on who you ask. At first this sounds counter intuitive; why would a low power mode gain popularity when the solar cycle is at an all time minimum?
A world of people on the go
Mobile phones tablets and laptops dominate the consumer electronics market for a good reason. We want our electronics to be where we are, not the other way around. We live in a world where one minute you may be renting an apartment in the city, and the next you might be living in a trailer out in the woods. Many households do not have the living space for a radio shack or putting up permanent antennas.
How could QRP possibly solve these issues? First let’s address the idea that we want our electronics to go with us. QRP equipment is light can be battery powered and is usually compact.
Many QRP radios are specifically designed to be taken backpacking, hiking, or outdoors and on some level. The Yaesu FT-817 (now 818) has been an industry standard for a long time and is designed for portable use. The entire industry surrounding QRP focuses on being able to get on the air from any location in just a few minutes. Then there’s the whole prepping movement which is a whole different topic. Many people have a compelling reason to own portable gear- even if you don’t consider all of the benefits of being able to operate anywhere.
Radio, or feeding the family?
QRP To The Rescue
The BITX40 is a great Single Sideband (voice) radio to get on the air with and the kit is self is only $59. It requires minimal soldering and wiring. If you are already into CW then the QRP Labs QCX is hard to beat at $49, and for the QRP Labs QSX All Mode Transceiver will be out soon for around $75 and is going to rock the industry. Take any of these radios and add in some coax cabling and some reclaimed wire for an antenna, and you will be on the air very quickly. Granted, it’s not beginner-friendly because you actually have to learn how the radio works how antennas work and how to operate; But that in itself is a great reason that QRP is “saving” ham radio- fewer appliance operators!
Modes and Codes
Here is where the digital modes like FT8 come in. With the radio input and output tied into a computer, digital modes can be used. A computer does the talking for you. FT8 is one such mode and that has expanded into JS8 Call. JS8 Call is a mode that is conversational and based on FT8. You can speak with people as if you were talking to them over a computer chat, all via HF radio. Transcontinental and transoceanic contacts are not only possible but are commonplace, even with low power output and simple antennas that can be erected anywhere, temporarily or otherwise.
9 comments
2 pings
Skip to comment form
In my opinion,with new technologies great receivers and all that nowadays,QRP should be 1 watt or less.This is not the 1930`s anymore…5 watts is too much for QRP !! Ham radio needs to go forward and forget the old junk…leave that for people who want to play with tubes and dials.
Im not intending to take up the 1 watt challenge yet, but want to say real radios are the ones you make, at 1 watt or 5. Thats what drives me to QRP. Thanks for a great article Ryan!!
I don’t want to talk to people. I do want to build things. QRP kits and the Joe Taylor modes are perfect.
A hundred different hobbies are available within ham radio, more power (hihi) to everyone who actually has fun in the hobby!
There was a point in time when 100 watts was QRP. QRPp IS less than a watt.
When I was a kid, new ham equipment was expensive, beyond even considering.
I’m not sure $500 today is harder to come by than $250 or whatever an HW-101 cost in 1972.
Both are out of reach for many 12 year olds but given the money people pay for cellphone charges and cable and internet, , a ham rig is probably more affordable today, except everyone “needs” all these subscriber services.
Fifty years ago many a kid got into ham radio with a horrible (and really unsuitable) low end general coverage receiver,and built a single tube transmitter (which may have put out more power than 5W).
You can do it today, except entry level for most hams is 2M FM. A portable digital tuned shortwave receiver is way better than the awful transistorized Hallicrafters S-120A I got in 1971, and I paid about the same in real money forty years apart. Then build a two transistor transmitter.
Little has changed, except equipment today, homebuilt or bought, may be better.
I’d like to test such modes and passed the exam recently. I’m thinking about buying DYI QRP named ILER-40. Is it possible to use FT8 or JS8 with this radio?
Author
Congrats on passing the exam! The ILER-40 probably won’t work. It uses a VXO (voltage controlled oscillator) for tuning, which will probably not tune the digital part of the band. With the digital tuning, it would probably work. I’d check with the seller to be sure 🙂
Thanks for the reply and congrats 🙂 Yes, with further seeking for info I realised this incompability. I can start with voice or just make my choice of equipment again. There’s plenty of time. 40m seems to be crowded though 🙂
[…] a ham radio operator on HF, then you likely know all about FT8 and what it’s done for (or to, depending on your perspective…) amateur radio. It’s made a simple 5 watt QRP station capable of truly worldwide […]
[…] en HF, entonces probablemente sepa todo acerca de FT8 y para qué se hace (o para, según su perspectiva …) la radioafición. ¡Es una simple estación QRP de 5 vatios capaz de contactos […]